Siphons how do they work

This tells us that if the height of the U-tube of a siphon were too great, the same thing would happen, and a near-vacuum would be created near the top of the U-tube. This would interrupt the continuity of liquid in the tube, and siphon action would stop. This is exactly what happens. Ancient Roman engineers who built siphons into their water aqueducts were quite aware of this limitation of siphons.

In this case we must be clear about the reason that the siphon would fail if the U-tube were too high. It is simply because air pressure on the input side is insufficient to raise the input liquid column as high as the top of the tube.

If it doesn't get to the top, it won't flow over to fall down the output tube. So air pressure is important to siphons by putting a limitation on how high they can lift water, and without lifting the water to the top of the U-tube, no siphon flow can occur. What sustains the liquid flow? But this isn't the whole story.

Is it air pressure that sustains the water flow in a siphon? It is not. If siphon flow is analyzed, with a nearly incompressible liquid like water, the work done at each end of the siphon against air pressure is NET zero, for equal volumes of air are displaced at each end. The two ends water surface in bucket and at the output end of the tube are both at the same atmospheric pressure, p , so pdV is the same size for equal volumes displaced, but the signs are opposite.

So air pressure does not drive the siphon. Siphoning in a vacuum. If there were no air pressure, could a siphon work? Yes, at least for some liquids, but something else would be required to cause the liquid to form a continuous path through the elevated U-tube.

Very cohesive liquids can do this, the molecules attracting each other so strongly that they can maintain a chain-like continuity up and across a U-tube, yet still maintain liquid properties. This has been demonstrated in the laboratory.

See: Siphon in a vacuum. So continuity of the liquid in the U-tube is essential for a siphon. The continuity can be sustained by external air pressure, but even in the absence of surrounding air, cohesive forces in some liquids are sufficient to pass over a modest height of the U-tube.

So we can conclude that air pressure is not always necessary to provide the conditions necessary for a siphon. But air pressure is never the reason that the liquid maintains flow through the siphon tube, for any kind of liquid.

The naive chain analogy. Maintaining the flow. Let's suppose we have the conditions necessary for a siphon, with liquid from the reservoir filling the tube. The output portion of the U-tube is necessarily longer than the length of the input portion measured from liquid level to top of U-tube. So it is all too tempting to think of this as something like a pulley and rope with unequal weights attached to the rope on either side.

Then the heavier weight "pulls down" the other one. This misconception is reinforced by thinking of the liquid in the tube by analogy with a smooth and flexible chain passing over a pulley. But that's the danger of naive analogies, they ultimately break down, for the two situations are never completely alike. A failed siphon model. A few years ago a journal article stimulated some controversy in journals and on the web.

Hughes, Stephen W. Physics Education, 45 2 , pp. Hughes exposed a serious error in dictionary definitions of "siphon", especiaially The Oxford English Dictionary definition: "A pipe or tube of glass, metal, or other material, bent so that one leg is longer than the other, and used for drawing off liquids by means of atmospheric pressure, which forces the liquid up the shorter leg and over the bend in the pipe.

But Hughes went on to propose cohesion and the "chain model" as the reason for siphon flow, ignoring the role of liquid pressure gradients. This chain model was refuted. See: Siphons, Revisited.

Alex Richert and P. Binder, University of Hawaii at Hilo. The Physics Teacher, Vol. Reverse siphon? Vittorio Zonca's mill. From Dircks Once the air is out and the liquid has reached the end of the tube, you must prevent any air from getting back in. To do this, maintain suction and carefully crimp the hose or use your thumb as a stopper. Now drop the end of the hose into the other container and release. Liquid should start traveling from the source container to the new one.

Be sure to keep an eye on your source liquid and make sure the hose stays fully submerged, otherwise you'll end up with bubbles. When you need to stop, lift the new container and hose higher than your source container. It may be the case that atmospheric pressure , gravity, and liquid cohesion all work together to make siphons work the way they do. Scientists will continue to study siphons to figure out once and for all how they work.

Maybe you could grow up to be the scientist who solves the mystery! Isn't science fascinating? Find a few friends and family members to help you check out the following activities:. How about this one, sam? Hi, Caleb! Thanks for stopping by Wonderopolis! Which experiment are you referring to? We always recommend you having an adult with you when doing any type of experiment.

Have fun! Hi, Wonder Friend! We're sorry to hear that. Unfortunately, sometimes the videos are blocked by you school or organization.

Luckily, most of the information is in the Wonder itself so you're not missing out! Hi, Joe! Great question! Thanks for checking back, Jace!

We're glad you had fun exploring the suggested Wonder. Unfortunately, we don't have that exact Wonder question. You can also submit your question to the Wonder Bank. All the Wonders are user submitted questions.

We are undergoing some spring clearing site maintenance and need to temporarily disable the commenting feature. Thanks for your patience. Drag a word to its definition. You have answered 0 of 3 questions correctly and your score is:.

Want to add a little wonder to your website? Help spread the wonder of families learning together. We sent you SMS, for complete subscription please reply. Follow Twitter Instagram Facebook.

How does a siphon work? How long have siphons been used? What physical forces are at work in a siphon? Wonder What's Next? Try It Out Isn't science fascinating? Find a few friends and family members to help you check out the following activities: Ready to see a siphon at work?

You'll need just a few simple supplies to do this fun Water Siphon Experiment. Be sure to check the online instructions and get help from an adult friend or family member. Once you have the hang of creating a siphon, step up your game by trying to create a colorful Siphon Water Coaster.

You'll find all the information you need online. Have fun and be sure to get help from an adult friend or family member. Up for a challenge? You're tasked with emptying a hot tub of its water. You don't have a pump.